Why does my <= statement not work?

I'm running a simple loop that applies a less than or equal to inequality to a value. Unfortunately, it is overlooking this value and not working. Here is my code
% Initial Conditions
clearvars
close all
Ms=1.989E30;
m = logspace(-2, 2, 400);
% m = 1E2:100:1E4
% (m<0.08, m**-0.3, numpy.where(m < 0.5, 0.08**-0.3 * (m/0.08)**-1.3, 0.08**-0.3 * (0.5/0.08)**-1.3 * (m/0.5)**-2.3))
%% def chabrier03individual(m):
k = 0.158*exp(-(-log(0.08))^2/(2*0.69^2))
if m<=1
u = 0.158*(1./m)*exp(-(log(m)-log(0.08))^2/(2 * 0.69^2));
else
v = k*m;
end

1 Kommentar

Stephen23
Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
Bearbeitet: Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
The comprison works as documented. Note the if documentation states " An expression is true when its result is nonempty and contains only nonzero elements (logical or real numeric). Otherwise, the expression is false."
You provided if with a 1x400 logical vector as its condition, it contains no non-zero elements:
>> nnz(m<=1)
ans = 0
Based on this I would expect the else part to be executed, and this is indeed what occurs when i run your code.
Note that your vector m contains just one value repeated 400 times over:
>> unique(m)
ans = 100
It is not clear why you wanted to create that 1x400 vector in such an obfuscated way.
EDIT: the OP originally defined
m = logspace(2, 2, 400);
but has since edited the question and changed it to:
m = logspace(-2, 2, 400);
The relevance of reading the if documentation is unchanged.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Antworten (1)

Shekhar Vats
Shekhar Vats am 31 Jan. 2020

0 Stimmen

Can you please say more about your issue ? It's working as expected for me.

7 Kommentare

HC98
HC98 am 31 Jan. 2020
Hi yes, I couldn't get the u value to print, It does not recognise that instruction.
Stephen23
Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
"I couldn't get the u value to print,"
Because your if condition is not true, I see no reason to expect u to be defined.
Stephen23
Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
HC98' "Answer" moved here:
Apologies, I made an error in my code, I've added the correct version here
HC98
HC98 am 31 Jan. 2020
U shoiuld be defined... the entire point of this function is to produce values for m less than 1.
Stephen23
Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
Bearbeitet: Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
"U shoiuld be defined."
No. Your non-scalar logical vector does not contain only non-zeros:
>> nnz(m<=1)
ans = 200
>> numel(m)
ans = 400
Read the if documenttion to understand why this is relevant.
Most likely using if is entirely the wrong approach anyway, and you should be using indexing.
HC98
HC98 am 31 Jan. 2020
All I need is a clue why it won't work. I'm trying to transcribe it in MATLAB having found a copy of the code in Python which reads:
def chabrier03individual(m):
k = 0.158 * exp(-(-log(0.08))**2/(2 * 0.69**2))
return numpy.where(m <= 1,\
0.158*(1./m) * exp(-(log(m)-log(0.08))**2/(2 * 0.69**2)),\
k*m**-2.3)
Stephen23
Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
Bearbeitet: Stephen23 am 31 Jan. 2020
The equivalent to numpy's where is to use indexing:
x = ...;
y = ...;
idx = m<=1;
z = y;
z(idx) = x(idx)

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Kategorien

Mehr zu Loops and Conditional Statements finden Sie in Hilfe-Center und File Exchange

Gefragt:

am 31 Jan. 2020

Bearbeitet:

am 31 Jan. 2020

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by