MATLAB Answers

possible to increase speed of power function applied to a vector?

27 views (last 30 days)
ER2018
ER2018 on 2 Jul 2018
Commented: ER2018 on 3 Jul 2018
Is it possible to increase speed of power function applied to a vector?
N=16e3;
X=-2+4*rand(N,1);
Y=10.^X;
I tried
Y=power(10,X);
But of course it gives me the same speed. Any ideas?

Answers (2)

Jan
Jan on 2 Jul 2018
No. power is expensive. There is no magic super power operator, which can do the same work in less time.
In some situations you can replace the power operation by accumulated multiplications:
a = rand;
X1 = a .^ (1:10);
X2 = cumprod(repmat(a, 1, 10));
But remember that this accumulates the rounding errors also, so for large powers it gets less accurate.
Another common case, where the power operation can be avoided:
a = 1.5 * 10^8 % Expensive power and multiplication
b = 1.5e8 % Cheap constant
Especially if this appear in loops or in functions to be integrated, the constant can save much time.

  1 Comment

ER2018
ER2018 on 3 Jul 2018
Thank you for the tips. Unfortunately there's no cheap constant I can use here, I really need the calculated values.
How would the solution with cumprod look in the example I provided?

Sign in to comment.


Yair Altman
Yair Altman on 3 Jul 2018
In addition to what Jan said, perhaps your in your specific case it is possible to work at the exponent level, i.e. not Y=10^X but rather log10Y=X, and then continue processing using log10Y rather than with Y. Depending on what you do with the data later in your code, it might possibly be faster since it avoids the initial power operation.

  1 Comment

ER2018
ER2018 on 3 Jul 2018
Yes, I do that when possible, but finally I do need to calculate the actual values 10.^X to use in the rest of the code.

Sign in to comment.

Sign in to answer this question.


Translated by