Need help about error for Area

8 Ansichten (letzte 30 Tage)
RG
RG am 4 Mai 2017
Kommentiert: dpb am 5 Mai 2017
Need to calculate area of triangle getting error with nargchk need help to fix it.
function area = area2d(x1,y1,x2,y2,x3,y3) %function definition
msg = nargchk(1,6,nargchk);%total 6 inputs
error(msg);%error message
area=0.5*(x1(y2-y3)-x2*(y1-y3)+x3*(y1-y2)); % area calculation from the given formula

Antworten (3)

Image Analyst
Image Analyst am 5 Mai 2017
Don't use area as the name of your variable. It's the name of a built in function.

dpb
dpb am 4 Mai 2017
Bearbeitet: dpb am 4 Mai 2017
You've got nargchk in the argument list as first problem...
function area = area2d(x1,y1,x2,y2,x3,y3)
error(nargchk(6,6,nargin))
...
Your function as written requires 6 and only 6 arguments, not a variable number from 1 to 6...
ADDENDUM It would be "more Matlab-y" to use x- and y- arrays instead of six individual elements in which case the number of arguments would be two and you'd then check for 3 elements in each. But, this refactoring could make the upper level code much more succinct.
  3 Kommentare
dpb
dpb am 4 Mai 2017
msg = error(nargchk(6,6,nargin));
Lose the assignment; error eats the message if it isn't null and throws the error...you're done at that point.
The line I coded was
error(nargchk(6,6,nargin))
altho I see I left off a closing parens; will fix that in Answer.
That's the only error-checking line you need (or want; there's no point is saving the message for anything).
dpb
dpb am 4 Mai 2017
On the warning regarding obsolescence, better practice given that would be to just write
narginchk(6,6)
and be done; it'll call error internally if needed.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.


Steven Lord
Steven Lord am 5 Mai 2017
In addition to the narg* usage dpb mentioned, look at the first part of your last line.
area=0.5*(x1(y2-y3) ...
You don't want to try to compute element number (y2-y3) of the variable x1. You want to multiply (y2-y3) by x1.
area=0.5*(x1*(y2-y3) ...
  1 Kommentar
dpb
dpb am 5 Mai 2017
Good catch, Steven, I didn't look at rest of code much (like at all).
In line with previous note on input as arrays instead of a bunch of named variables, OP may want to consider
doc polyarea
--Matlab has the functionality already supplied.
On IA's note re: use of area, it won't hurt here as it's the internal name of the return variable that goes away once the function executes so won't alias the plotting area function, but is an important point in general. If assigns the result of the function in the calling context, it would.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Kategorien

Mehr zu Data Type Conversion finden Sie in Help Center und File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by