Locate elements of a vector inside a meshgrid

I'm trying to build a matrix RES, with the same dimensions of X and Y, that has a '1' in the position pointed (with a tollerance tollX and tollY) by the i-th couple contained in V.
[X,Y]=meshgrid(0:1:3,-2:1:2);
V=[2.1 1.2;
0.2 0.7;
3.1 1.9;
1.6 -1];
tollX=0.5;
tollY=0.5;
RES=0;
for i=1:length(V)
RES=(V(i,1)<X+tollX).*(V(i,1)>X-tollX).*(V(i,2)<Y+tollY).*(V(i,2)>Y-tollY)+RES;
end
This "rough" solution works well with small meshgrids and V, but since i have to manage far bigger data sets i would like to vectorize and refine the code to get better performances.
P.S. I expected '&' operator to be faster in general than ' .* ', but this doesn't seem to be true, at least for my case.
To test this I simply changed the statement inside the for loop with this one:
RES=((V(i,1)<X+tollX)&(V(i,1)>X-tollX)&(V(i,2)<Y+tollY)&(V(i,2)>Y-tollY))|RES;

Antworten (1)

Rik
Rik am 6 Okt. 2020

0 Stimmen

I would suggest using ismembertol, or consider functions like normxcorr2 from the image processing toolbox.

3 Kommentare

Alberto Belvedere
Alberto Belvedere am 6 Okt. 2020
Bearbeitet: Alberto Belvedere am 6 Okt. 2020
I saw the possibility of using either bxsfun or find. Is there any advantage in terms of speed by using ismembertol, rather than those two funtions?
Rik
Rik am 6 Okt. 2020
I'm not quite sure how implicit expansion (with bsxfun) would increase performance. I suspect ismembertol would be more efficient. I also don't necessarily see how find would be useful.
Thanks, i'll do some tests to see which one performs better.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Kategorien

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by