legend symbol disappears when plotting a polyshape

If there is not any output from the legend, the symbol of the polyshape is visible:

p=plot(polyshape([0 0 1 1],[1 0 0 1]));
legend(p);

Instead, if I try to get both outputs of the legend with a polyshape, the symbol of the polyshape disappears:

p=plot(polyshape([0 0 1 1],[1 0 0 1]));
[h,objh]=legend(p);

How can I still see/visualise the symbol of the polyshape, when I need to get both outputs of the legend?

[Sim]

Hi, any suggestion? :-)

[Adam Danz]

How are you using the second output? Why do you need it? I'm interested.

As @Star Strider mentioned, additional outputs after the first output to legend are not documented and have led to all sorts of issues. The option to request additional outputs to legend will be removed in the future.

[Star Strider]

@Adam Danz — Some of that capability — among which are the ability to change the marker and line properties only in the legend — needs to be preserved somehow, if the second output is eliminated. Perhaps those can be part of the Children field, or even a new field. Eliminiating the second output could break a lot of existing code.

[Sim]

Hi @Adam Danz! Sorry for my late reply.... :-) I would need the second output to increase the marker/symbol size of other plots in the legend, as explained in How can I change the marker size in legend?. Something like this:

hold on
s=plot(rand(1,5),rand(1,5),'o','MarkerSize',8,'MarkerFaceColor','b');
p=plot(polyshape([0 0 1 1],[1 0 0 1]));
[h,objh]=legend([p s]);
% increase the markers size
icons=findobj(objh,'Marker','o');
set(icons,'MarkerSize',15);

[Adam Danz]

Thanks for share the use cases @Sim & @Star Strider.

Answer 1

[Star Strider]

I don’t have any specific suggestions.

It works with one output, however not more than one. That the legend function has more than oue output is not documented, nor are the behaviours associated with the additional outputs. The second output (‘objh1’ here) can be used to change the marker properties, however without markers, there is nothing to change. (Experimenting with its properties didn’t bring back the patch in the legend.) Since the additional outputs are undocumented, you will likely need to Contact Support and ask about this. Also, ask for published documentation on the additional outputs be made freely available.

Include the URL of this thread in your note to MathWorks so you don’t have to repeat all this.

figure
p=plot(polyshape([0 0 1 1],[1 0 0 1]));
h = legend(p);

get(h)

            AutoUpdate: on
       BackgroundAlpha: 1
          BeingDeleted: off
                   Box: on
            BusyAction: 'queue'
         ButtonDownFcn: @bdowncb
              Children: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
                 Color: [1 1 1]
           ContextMenu: [1x1 ContextMenu]
             CreateFcn: ''
             DeleteFcn: ''
             Direction: 'normal'
         DirectionMode: 'auto'
             EdgeColor: [0.1500 0.1500 0.1500]
             FontAngle: 'normal'
              FontName: 'Helvetica'
              FontSize: 9
            FontWeight: 'normal'
      HandleVisibility: 'on'
               HitTest: on
           Interpreter: 'tex'
         Interruptible: off
            ItemHitFcn: @defaultItemHitCallback
                Layout: [0x0 matlab.ui.layout.LayoutOptions]
             LineWidth: 0.5000
              Location: 'northeast'
            NumColumns: 1
        NumColumnsMode: 'auto'
           Orientation: 'vertical'
                Parent: [1x1 Figure]
         PickableParts: 'visible'
              Position: [0.7327 0.8568 0.1529 0.0439]
              Selected: off
    SelectionHighlight: on
                String: {'data1'}
                   Tag: 'legend'
             TextColor: [0 0 0]
                 Title: [1x1 Text]
                  Type: 'legend'
                 Units: 'normalized'
              UserData: []
               Visible: on

figure
p=plot(polyshape([0 0 1 1],[1 0 0 1]));
[h,objh1,objh2]=legend(p);

get(h)

            AutoUpdate: off
       BackgroundAlpha: 1
          BeingDeleted: off
                   Box: on
            BusyAction: 'queue'
         ButtonDownFcn: @bdowncb
              Children: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
                 Color: [1 1 1]
           ContextMenu: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
             CreateFcn: ''
             DeleteFcn: ''
             Direction: 'normal'
         DirectionMode: 'auto'
             EdgeColor: [0.1500 0.1500 0.1500]
             FontAngle: 'normal'
              FontName: 'Helvetica'
              FontSize: 9
            FontWeight: 'normal'
      HandleVisibility: 'on'
               HitTest: on
           Interpreter: 'tex'
         Interruptible: off
            ItemHitFcn: @defaultItemHitCallback
                Layout: [0x0 matlab.ui.layout.LayoutOptions]
             LineWidth: 0.5000
              Location: 'northeast'
            NumColumns: 1
        NumColumnsMode: 'auto'
           Orientation: 'vertical'
                Parent: [1x1 Figure]
         PickableParts: 'visible'
              Position: [0.7327 0.8568 0.1529 0.0439]
              Selected: off
    SelectionHighlight: on
                String: {'data1'}
                   Tag: 'legend'
             TextColor: [0 0 0]
                 Title: [1x1 Text]
                  Type: 'legend'
                 Units: 'normalized'
              UserData: []
               Visible: on

get(objh1)

       AffectAutoLimits: off
        BackgroundColor: 'none'
           BeingDeleted: off
             BusyAction: 'queue'
          ButtonDownFcn: ''
               Children: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
               Clipping: off
                  Color: [0 0 0]
              ColorMode: 'manual'
            ContextMenu: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
              CreateFcn: ''
              DeleteFcn: ''
              EdgeColor: 'none'
                Editing: off
                 Extent: [0.5467 0.1053 0.4091 0.7895]
              FontAngle: 'normal'
               FontName: 'Helvetica'
               FontSize: 9
          FontSmoothing: on
              FontUnits: 'points'
             FontWeight: 'normal'
       HandleVisibility: 'on'
                HitTest: off
    HorizontalAlignment: 'left'
           Interactions: []
            Interpreter: 'tex'
          Interruptible: off
              LineStyle: '-'
              LineWidth: 0.5000
                 Margin: 3
                 Parent: [1x1 Legend]
          PickableParts: 'visible'
               Position: [0.5467 0.5000 0]
               Rotation: 0
               Selected: off
     SelectionHighlight: off
            SeriesIndex: 'none'
                 String: 'data1'
                    Tag: ''
                   Type: 'text'
                  Units: 'data'
               UserData: []
      VerticalAlignment: 'middle'
                Visible: on

get(objh2)

    AlignVertexCenters: off
            Annotation: [1x1 matlab.graphics.eventdata.Annotation]
          BeingDeleted: off
            BusyAction: 'queue'
         ButtonDownFcn: ''
              Children: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
              Clipping: on
           ContextMenu: [0x0 GraphicsPlaceholder]
             CreateFcn: ''
             DeleteFcn: ''
           DisplayName: 'data1'
             EdgeAlpha: 1
             EdgeColor: [0 0 0]
             FaceAlpha: 0.3500
             FaceColor: [0 0.4470 0.7410]
         FaceColorMode: 'auto'
      HandleVisibility: 'on'
               HitTest: on
         HoleEdgeAlpha: 1
     HoleEdgeAlphaMode: 'auto'
         HoleEdgeColor: [0 0 0]
     HoleEdgeColorMode: 'auto'
         Interruptible: on
              LineJoin: 'round'
             LineStyle: '-'
             LineWidth: 0.5000
                Parent: [1x1 Axes]
         PickableParts: 'visible'
              Selected: off
    SelectionHighlight: on
           SeriesIndex: 1
                 Shape: [1x1 polyshape]
                   Tag: ''
                  Type: 'polygon'
              UserData: []
               Visible: on

.