I have a logical array like this:
I want to extrat the colum index of the cells where the first instance of 1 is detected. Like this:
For example, you see here that the first two rows show 4, because that is where 1 is first detected.

 Akzeptierte Antwort

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson am 2 Mai 2022
C = sum(cumprod(~X, 2),1) + 1;
C will be one more than the number of columns for any row that has no 1.

4 Kommentare

Pelajar UM
Pelajar UM am 2 Mai 2022
Bearbeitet: Pelajar UM am 2 Mai 2022
This works, with a little adjustment:
C = sum(cumprod(~X, 2),2) + 1;
Now imagine X was computed inside a for loop. In the example above, k=1:5000
Is there a way to stop the loop before 5000 when all the rows have at least a 1?
Basically, I have a difficult time bringing C inside the loop and getting reasonable results....
idx = find(sum(A,2)==0)
if idx == []
break
end
But I don't know if it's more time-consuming to check the above condition for each k or to make MATLAB build the matrix A completely and to check the condition after the loop has finished.
Pelajar UM
Pelajar UM am 3 Mai 2022
Bearbeitet: Pelajar UM am 3 Mai 2022
Thanks @Torsten. The second line gives a warning:
Unexpected use of '[' in a scalar context.
And it appears to break the loop already in k=1.
Instead we can use
if isempty(idx) == 1
break
end
But checking idx in every loop takes longer.
Method 1: 22 seconds
Method 2: 528 seconds
isempty(idx)

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Weitere Antworten (1)

Jonas
Jonas am 2 Mai 2022

0 Stimmen

use the find() function together with a loop over each row

1 Kommentar

Pelajar UM
Pelajar UM am 2 Mai 2022
Bearbeitet: Pelajar UM am 2 Mai 2022
Like this?
Doesn't work, because it doesn't find the first instance. It finds all the indices that meet this condition.
for p=1:n %n is the length of the logical array X
G(p,:)=find (X(p,:));
end

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Kategorien

Tags

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by