Why is the "int" function not evaluating my integral? The "r" variable still has the "int" in it.
clear
clc
theta_s = 0:0.5:pi/2;
syms theta_v phi
for i = 1:length(theta_s)
integ2(i) = ((((1/(2*pi))*((pi-phi)*cos(phi) + sin(phi))*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)-(1/pi)*(tan(theta_s(i))+tan(theta_v)+sqrt(tan(theta_v)^2 + tan(theta_s(i))^2 - 2*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)*cos(phi)))))*cos(theta_v)*sin(theta_v));
r(i)= int((integ2(i)), theta_v, [0 pi/2]);
end

1 Kommentar

Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson am 3 Mär. 2022
What reason do you have to lead you to expect that there is a closed form integral?

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

 Akzeptierte Antwort

David Hill
David Hill am 3 Mär. 2022

0 Stimmen

theta_s = 0:0.5:pi/2;
syms theta_v
phi=pi/6;%choose a phi or loop for various values of phi
for i = 1:length(theta_s)
integ2(i) = ((((1/(2*pi))*((pi-phi)*cos(phi) + sin(phi))*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)-(1/pi)*(tan(theta_s(i))+tan(theta_v)+sqrt(tan(theta_v)^2 + tan(theta_s(i))^2 - 2*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)*cos(phi)))))*cos(theta_v)*sin(theta_v));
r(i)= vpaintegral((integ2(i)), theta_v, [0 pi/2]);
end

6 Kommentare

Ali Almakhmari
Ali Almakhmari am 3 Mär. 2022
But I need an answer in terms of phi
Torsten
Torsten am 3 Mär. 2022
If "int" does not return an analytical expression for the integral in terms of phi, you'll have to be satisfied with an evaluation for different numerical values of phi.
AndresVar
AndresVar am 4 Mär. 2022
@Ali Almakhmari the square root part is too complicated to find a simplified closed form. Could there be a typo or maybe use some identity to simplify?
Ali Almakhmari
Ali Almakhmari am 4 Mär. 2022
Actually I forgot to say this, but after integrating this function in terms of theta_v, I will do another integration in terms of phi from 0 to pi, so am not looking for a symbolic answer at the end if that helps. I just don't how to do it because matlab is not evaulating it even with two int functions (for theta_v and phi)
Works fine.
theta_s = 0:0.5:pi/2;
syms theta_v phi
for i = 1:length(theta_s)
integ2(i) = ((((1/(2*pi))*((pi-phi)*cos(phi) + sin(phi))*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)-(1/pi)*(tan(theta_s(i))+tan(theta_v)+sqrt(tan(theta_v)^2 + tan(theta_s(i))^2 - 2*tan(theta_s(i))*tan(theta_v)*cos(phi)))))*cos(theta_v)*sin(theta_v));
r(i)= vpaintegral(vpaintegral((integ2(i)), theta_v, [0 pi/2]),phi,[0 pi]);
end
Walter Roberson
Walter Roberson am 6 Mär. 2022
By the way, integrating first with respect to phi is faster.
At one point I saw a closed form solution for integration with respect to phi, but I was not able to reproduce that later.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Weitere Antworten (0)

Kategorien

Mehr zu Mathematics finden Sie in Hilfe-Center und File Exchange

Produkte

Version

R2020b

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by