Help me understand!

5 Ansichten (letzte 30 Tage)
Nour Butrus
Nour Butrus am 14 Feb. 2022
Kommentiert: AndresVar am 16 Feb. 2022
I am presented with a task of simulating the movement of three bodies with a constant mass using Newton's laws.
The task is very easy to follow and I have no trouble understanding it, until it comes to solving the differential equation using Runge-Kutta, where M is the mass of a body, is the second derivative of the position, namely, the acceleration and F is the force applied on M due to the two other masses.
Please refer to task number 3 below
Where equation 3 is I am finding it particularly difficult to understand why the right hand of the equation is a column consisten of what appears to be the velocity V for each body and the acceleration .
I would highly appreciate any guidance to the interpertation of the task!
  2 Kommentare
David Hill
David Hill am 14 Feb. 2022
Show us what you have done (your code) and ask a specific question.
Nour Butrus
Nour Butrus am 14 Feb. 2022
Hey! Below are the tasks I am asked to solve, with the my code.
I am a 2nd year undergraduate student so I apologise that it is not perfect :)
Task 1
clc
clear all
%task #1
%Initial conditions
p=0.05;
P1=[0,0,0]; V1=[p,p,p];
P2=[1,0,0]; V2=[-p,p,p];
P3=[0,0,1]; V3=[-p,-p,-p];
V0=transpose([P1 V1 P2 V2 P3 V3]);
%Masses/Scalars M_i
M1=1; M2=2; M3=0.5;
Task 2
function F= Force(P,M,P1,M1,P2,M2)
F=((-1)*(M*M1).*(P-P1)/((norm(P-P1).^3)))-(1*M*M2.*(P-P2)./((norm(P-P2)).^3));
end
Task 3
function Y=RHS(t,X)
F1=Force(P1,M1,P2,M2,P3,M3);
F2=Force(P2,M2,P1,M1,P3,M3);
F3=Force(P3,M3,P1,M1,P2,M2);
Y=[{V1} {F1./M1} {V2} {F2./M2} {V3} {F3./M3}];
end

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Akzeptierte Antwort

AndresVar
AndresVar am 14 Feb. 2022
Bearbeitet: AndresVar am 16 Feb. 2022
Equation 3 is a 2nd order system p''=..., the RK3 is given for 1st order p'=...(see it's first difference ) =..)
See for example equation 14 here: part1.pdf (nyu.edu)
you can see how order is reduced by introducing firts time derivatives (V's) as new variables
  2 Kommentare
Nour Butrus
Nour Butrus am 15 Feb. 2022
Thanks a lot! So it is the case that I have to represent my initial values of and values of calculated with the intital positions in the vector Y, but am I mistaken to understand that I have to use that vector as to implement Runge-Kutta?
AndresVar
AndresVar am 16 Feb. 2022
f = Y = RHS(t,X). The RHS you commented above looks good just make sure P1=X(1), V1=X(2)... etc as defined in task#1. You didn't say, but I guess velocity is constant?
% at t0
Y0 = RHS(t0,X0)
% one step later Y(t0+h)=Y1
K1=h*Y0;
K2=h*RHS(t+h/2,Y0+h/2);
K3=...
Y1 = Y0 + 1/6(K1+4*K2+K3)
% two steps later Y(t0+2h)=Y2
K1=h*Y1;
K2=...
K3=...
Y2 = Y1 + 1/6(K1+4*K2+K3)
code repeats, so just turn it into a loop for N steps
h = 0.01;
t(1) = 0;
Y(1)=RHS(t0,X0) %initial
for ii = 1:N
t(ii+1) = t(ii)+h
K1 =...
K2 =...
K3 =...
Y(ii+1) = Y(ii)+1/6(K1+4*K2+K3);
end
plot the forces vs time to see if they behave nicely... if not then you can play with the step size h

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Weitere Antworten (0)

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by