"char" doesn't always maintain orientation of input array

1 Ansicht (letzte 30 Tage)
FM
FM am 8 Nov. 2022
Bearbeitet: FM am 9 Nov. 2022
The "char" function maintains orientation of input arrays except for categorical arrays:
>> categorical(["A" "B"])
ans = 1×2 categorical array
A B
>> char(categorical(["A" "B"]))
ans = 2×1 char array
'A'
'B'
Does anyone know the rationale behind this?

Antworten (1)

Voss
Voss am 8 Nov. 2022
I imagine the rationale is that, in case the elements of the categorical array are multiple characters long, e.g.:
categorical(["Abbot" "Beto"])
ans = 1×2 categorical array
Abbot Beto
You want to be able to know where one ends and the next one begins, so you put them on different rows:
char(categorical(["Abbot" "Beto"]))
ans = 2×5 char array
'Abbot' 'Beto '
as opposed to having the result be:
'AbbotBeto'
ans = 'AbbotBeto'
which can be ambiguous:
categorical(["0" "1" "10" "11"])
ans = 1×4 categorical array
0 1 10 11
char(categorical(["0" "1" "10" "11"]))
ans = 4×2 char array
'0 ' '1 ' '10' '11'
since in this case '011011' could be interpreted as '0', '1', '10', '11', or as '0', '11', '0', '11', for example.
Just a guess.
  1 Kommentar
FM
FM am 9 Nov. 2022
Bearbeitet: FM am 9 Nov. 2022
Thanks for the speculation, Voss. I see this as trading one kind of ambiguity for another. The new ambiguity is that you can't tell whether the original array was a row or column vector.
It's odd that char doesn't use the same approach for string and categorical arrays:
>> char(["dog" "catty"])
1×5×2 char array
ans(:,:,1) = 'dog '
ans(:,:,2) = 'catty'
>> char(categorical(["dog" "catty"]))
ans = 2×5 char array
'dog '
'catty'
In fact, the categorical array is treated the same as a cell array of char arrays:
>> char({'dog';'catty'})
ans = 2×5 char array
'dog '
'catty'

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Produkte


Version

R2022a

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by