Structure from shaperead: Logical indexing gives a 'one row shift'

1 Ansicht (letzte 30 Tage)
Water_RC
Water_RC am 24 Jun. 2017
Beantwortet: Mudambi Srivatsa am 27 Jun. 2017
Dear all, I am facing a issue regarding logical indexing of elements in a structure loaded from a 'shaperead' call.
Indeed, what I did: (1) I load a shape file of points (let's say 'myPoints'), with one field of interest, which is -let's say- 'ID'. (2) Once loaded, I add a new field 'Cluster' with a for loop:
for i=1:length(names)
try
myPoints([myPoints.ID]==str2double(names(i,:))).Cluster=T(i);
catch
disp(['No point for point n°',names(i,:)]) % This can happen
end
end
note that the array 'names' is the same length as 'T'. Each line in 'names' refers to the field 'ID' in the structure, and I join the corresponding 'T' value to the field 'Cluster'
(3) I prepare a List of clusters and desired colors for mapping:
ListOfClusters=unique(T);
ListOfColors=distinguishable_colors(length(ListOfClusters));
Until here, everything goes great: When I look at the structure 'myPoints', the right value of 'Cluster' is attached to the right row/observation.
Then comes the mapping and I thought building a loop, which plots all the points of a certain cluster with a specific predefined color ('ListOfColors'), then map the next cluster, etc.
figure
hold on
for i=1:length(ListOfClusters)
StyleOfPoints=makesymbolspec('Point',{'Default','Marker','o','MarkerFaceColor',ListOfColors(i,:),'MarkerEdgeColor',ListOfColors(i,:)});
MappedPoints(i)=mapshow(myPoints([myPoints(:).Cluster]==ListOfClusters(i)),'SymbolSpec',StyleOfPoints);
MappedPoints(i).DisplayName=num2str(ListOfClusters(i),'Cluster %d');
end
Here is the problem: The logical indexing:
[myPoints(:).Cluster]==ListOfClusters(i)
returns the wrong index for all loop iteration, and it is always shifted to the previous row(s) from the right one(s). For instance, Cluster value of 7 has only one observation at row 35, but the previous logical indexing returns a 1 in column 34 (This is how I first tracked the problem). This seems to be the same problem for all values of Cluster and I can not realise what I did wrong...
Does anyone have an idea? Thanks!
PS: I can send sample data if needed.

Antworten (1)

Mudambi Srivatsa
Mudambi Srivatsa am 27 Jun. 2017
I am surprised that the issue is with logical indexing. How about using "find" to get the index of the matching cluster ID as follows:
find([myPoints(:).Cluster] == ListOfClusters(i))
Also, it would be a good idea to verify the values being compared. I suggest putting a breakpoint to watch the values of [myPoints(:).Cluster] and ListOfClusters(i)

Kategorien

Mehr zu Matrix Indexing finden Sie in Help Center und File Exchange

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by