I use str2fun(...) to create a function handle from a user-inputted string. I want to be able to run a check to make sure the function created is valid and no typos were made. I could not find a way to do this. Any suggestions?
Thanks, Ryan
MATLAB R2014a

1 Kommentar

What is a "valid" function handle?
f = @quit; % NOTE: Don't execute f if you have data in your MATLAB session you need!
f is a "valid" function handle in that it won't error when called. But you may not want users to enter 'quit' as the user-inputted string and blindly evaluate that function handle -- the "Bobby Tables" scenario.
g = @() zeros(1:12); % MAY error or MAY succeed and take a LONG time doing so
This may successfully execute (though it may take a while) or may throw an error depending on your computer's memory availability and your MATLAB settings. Is it "valid"?

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

 Akzeptierte Antwort

Kurt Schmutz
Kurt Schmutz am 18 Sep. 2014

1 Stimme

Hi Ryan
To CHECK whether a function handle is valid or not (without trial-and-error) you can do the following:
f = str2func('nameofthefunction')
fh = functions(f)
if isempty(fh.file)
% invalid :(
else
% valid :)
end
Note: file "nameofthefunction.m" must be in the current folder
Cheers, Kurt
MATLAB R2013b

4 Kommentare

This could fail if the function is an anonymous function which doesn't have a file.
x = @(x)x^2;
Kurt Schmutz
Kurt Schmutz am 22 Sep. 2014
Hi Sean,
obviously it will fail in this case!
Thanks for the hint :)
Ryan
Ryan am 22 Sep. 2014
Thanks Kurt. This worked for me since the function being used will never be anonymous.
Ryan
David Sinex
David Sinex am 26 Feb. 2021
This fails if the function is a class member.

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Weitere Antworten (3)

Sean de Wolski
Sean de Wolski am 1 Jul. 2014

0 Stimmen

try
fun()
catch
disp 'didn''t work'
end
Try it and catch failures. Or provide a listbox with known functions to remove the human typing element.
Ryan
Ryan am 1 Jul. 2014

0 Stimmen

I thought about the try, catch method but I want to be more descriptive in the error returned. I do not know all the known functions as it is a user created function that they are using instead of a default one.

1 Kommentar

Well if you catch the MException, you could look at the message of it.
...
catch ME
ME.message
end

Melden Sie sich an, um zu kommentieren.

Jos (10584)
Jos (10584) am 19 Sep. 2014

0 Stimmen

You might be interested in the function ISFUNCTION .

Kategorien

Mehr zu Scope Variables and Generate Names finden Sie in Hilfe-Center und File Exchange

Produkte

Community Treasure Hunt

Find the treasures in MATLAB Central and discover how the community can help you!

Start Hunting!

Translated by